Like the other sets, this one comes with a limited 10-year warranty. The ease of cleaning was a plus for several users, but there were complaints that the non-stick coating only lasted a few uses. Many cooks and chefs consider precise temperature control to be an advantage. This Gotham Steel set is comprehensive, cuisinart knife including even a 5-piece bake set. The first is to not pay too much heed to the informercials which are sale advertisements not guides on how to use the pans. There is currently a class-action lawsuit that claims Gotham Steel pans are not non-stick, despite advertising to the contrary.
All these brands are extremely similar, with the orange interior and stainless handles. The most generous estimate is that ceramic nonstick will last for about as long as PTFE, which is estimated to be 1-5 gotham steel cookware sets years. But in reality, ceramic nonstick loses its nonstick properties quickly. If you read reviews, you’ll find many that say the nonstick coating lasted less than a year; in some cases, only a few months.
I swap between this pan and a Tramontina Professional pan every couple of weeks. So the Nordic Ware pan doesn’t get as much use as it would if it were my only nonstick skillet. I cook eggs almost every day, and I can confidently say that both pans wear and age the same. The Tramontina Professional skillet will always be ever-so-slightly slicker than the Nordic Ware pan, due to the former’s smoother surface.
In the two years since we first recommended the Nordic Ware pan, we can attest that it maintains its nonstick properties when it’s properly used and cared for. The Tramontina Professional pan’s nonstick coating is smooth and slick. We found that it easily released food through repeated tests. Pale-yellow omelets effortlessly slid from this pan, as did tilapia fillets.
A number of new cookware startups offer nonstick skillets, but most are pricey and have persistent stock issues. Material Kitchen’s 10.5-inch pan is currently $95, which is more than we think you should pay for a piece of cookware with such a limited lifespan. The OXO Good Grips Pro nonstick anodized aluminum skillet feels solid and well made. But it lacks enough bend in the lip to prevent grease and sauce from dribbling down the side of the pan while pouring.
We cooked about 2 dozen eggs, and we noticed that even with butter, the eggs were sticking to the pan worse at the end than at the beginning. A small pat of butter, about a teaspoon made a huge difference. The over easy egg flipped right over and slid out of the pan. The Original line of Gotham Steel donotwork with induction cooktops. PTFE cookware also used a compound called PFOA in the manufacturing process.
Nonstick cookware of both types is technically recyclable, but many curbside recycling programs don’t take nonstick cookware because it requires a special recycling process. You may be able to find programs in your area, or programs you can mail your old pans to. I wish the bigger frying pan was a little larger, but it works and they are very easy to clean. Food does NOT stick and when washed they are not easily scratched. Nonstick food releaseNonstick food release score reflects the nonstick qualities of a pan’s interior by cooking four eggs consecutively without oil. To assess nonstick durability, we intentionally abraded frying-pan surfaces with steel wool until the coating was worn through or up to 2,000 strokes.
The copper exterior provides an elegant appearance for what is a relatively affordable cookware set. There is a good deal of variety offered among each cookware set, and so it is easy to find something no matter what type of nonstick pans you’re looking for. If you are new to cooking or are looking for a reliable set of cookware, the Original Cookware Collection is good option for everyday use. This feature is one that surprised us significantly while reviewing the Gotham Steel cookware set.
Both pans are made from lightweight, even-heating cast aluminum. The most noticeable difference between the two skillets is that the Nordic Ware pan’s nonstick surface is a little rougher to the touch than the Tramontina pan’s . But that didn’t affect the Nordic Ware pan’s nonstick effectiveness. We were still able to flip fried eggs and roll up fluffy yellow omelets with ease. The reason this pan is not our top pick is that it typically costs a little more than the Tramontina pan, and they perform virtually the same.
Now a stay-at-home dad, William has brought his passion for professional cooking home, where he continues to cook and bake for his wife and daughter. If you’re ok getting one or two years out of an inexpensive product, then there’s nothing wrong with the Gotham Steel pan. As far as investing in an entire set, I would recommend a test run first. If considering a set of this size it would be a good idea to test drive one of their pans first. That will give a good idea of the set’s performance before making a commitment to such a large number of pieces. The fry pan is a good size that will perform a variety of tasks well.