This was less of a cooking test and more of a cleaning test, but one that’s near and dear to my heart. Every toaster oven comes with an aluminum baking sheet with a nonstick coating, but some are much easier to clean than others. The Comfee was fairly accurate too, although it ran an average of 22 degrees hotter than the temp I set it for. If you’re looking for a basic toaster oven for your morning staples, the Comfee is simple, small and does the most basic toaster tasks well. It also held heat more consistently than any other oven, likely due to its small size and lack of a convection fan, which moves hot air around. It’s a contender for being the best toaster oven for those who want a side oven for extra tasks.
You can only do so once the oven reaches the selected temperature. With our Toast test, we were able to determine that level 4—5 minutes 10 seconds on the timer—was the best option scoring a 7/10. Levels 3 and 5 respectively had a lighter and darker than ideal, although even, surface color. The time it takes to toast a full batch of bread at the medium setting.
When set to 375˚ Fahrenheit and allowed it to preheat, our testing thermometer fluctuated between 400˚ and 425˚ — much hotter than the set temperature. When we cranked the temperature higher, that discrepancy shrunk a bit. For example, when we set the temperature to 400˚, the actual temperature never got above 410˚.
The air circulation and power provided the best cooking results for every food we tried, including tricky coconut shrimp and Brussels sprouts. It’s quiet enough to run in a busy kitchen, and the nonstick interior makes cleanup easy. It’s no surprise this is also one of the best-rated air fryers black decker air fryer by thousands of shoppers — all of our tests confirmed it’s a great option for most kitchen needs. The capabilities of both can vary, and the best air fryer results are determined by convection power (how consistently the heat rotates through) and the capacity of the basket or tray.
There are plenty of super-cheap toasters for the uber budget buyers, and plenty of toaster ovens that cost multiple times the price of this one. While this isn’t going to do as much as one of the large, expensive models, this does a great job with the tasks it’s built for. When we used this for toasting, the crumbs fell onto the removable crumb tray, which was easy to remove and clean.
Still, for the low price and the powerful cooking options it offers, this small appliance is a great option for any single person or small household. While you can only set the timer for 30 minutes, which is average for a device this size, you can also turn the dial to the Stay On setting if you want it to cook even longer. The cord only measured 26 inches long, which made it a little harder to reach an outlet. We found it easier to use cords that were at least 30 inches long in our tests, like the one that comes with the Hamilton Beach 31334. Three grocery store English muffins, cut in half to make six pieces, fit into the toaster but it was a bit of a tight fit.